Comedy Legend Reveals Two Films He Calls 'Literally Perfection'
A veteran comedian shares his picks for the only comedies that have truly withstood the test of time, explaining why certain films remain flawless while others fade away.
Comedy actors face constant pressure to stay current as humor shifts rapidly across generations. Martin Short knows this challenge well. The veteran performer has managed to bridge decades of entertainment, from his breakout roles in 1980s and '90s classics to his recent success on Hulu's hit series Only Murders in the Building alongside Steve Martin and Selena Gomez.
Predicting which comedies will age gracefully proves nearly impossible. Short's own filmography demonstrates this unpredictability. Movies like Captain Ron and Three Amigos received lukewarm critical reception initially but later developed devoted cult followings. Even Clifford, which Roger Ebert demolished in his review, now enjoys recognition as a 'so-bad-it's-good' gem.
The Timeless Comedy Standard
During a recent interview with Screen Slate, Short acknowledged that "tastes change through the years." Yet he identified two comedic masterpieces that transcend generational preferences. "I just think it's always interesting, particularly with comedy, what ages well and what doesn't," Short explained. "I mean, I can still look at Young Frankenstein, and I think it's literally perfection, and I feel that about Annie Hall. There are certain films that just have never been altered by time, and some have become less funny with time, and some become funnier."
Young Frankenstein represents an inspired choice. Mel Brooks crafted this parody with genuine affection for Universal's classic monster movies. The film's popularity has only grown, boosted by its successful Broadway musical adaptation. Today, Young Frankenstein commands the same respect as James Whale's original Frankenstein films.
Complex Legacy Questions
Annie Hall presents a more complicated case. The romantic comedy established templates that countless films still follow today. Yet discussions about the movie inevitably involve its creator, Woody Allen, whose Hollywood career effectively ended amid personal controversies. Despite the uncomfortable conversations surrounding Allen's legacy, the film remains significant for Diane Keaton's remarkable performance and its influence on the genre.
Short maintains characteristic modesty about his own work, though he's appeared in several films designed for universal, lasting appeal. Father of the Bride showcased one of his finest performances in a beloved family comedy. More recently, audiences have begun appreciating his inspired work in Paul Thomas Anderson's noir mystery Inherent Vice, which initially divided critics and viewers.