Spider-Man Fans Reject Zendaya's Return in MCU Future
Marvel enthusiasts are divided over whether MJ should reunite with Peter Parker after No Way Home's emotional ending left the world forgetting Spider-Man's identity.
The conclusion of Spider-Man: No Way Home left audiences devastated when Peter Parker's identity was erased from everyone's memory, including his girlfriend MJ, portrayed by Zendaya. While some fans eagerly anticipate her potential return in Spider-Man: Brand New Day, others believe bringing her back would undermine the previous film's powerful finale.
Many supporters prefer introducing fresh romantic interests from the comic books, possibly through Sadie Sink's mysterious casting in the upcoming movie. A recent fan theory suggests Sink might play Jean Grey, serving as a temporary love interest before helping restore MJ's memories of Peter.
Fan Theory Sparks Heated Debate
The speculation proposes that Sink's character would briefly date Peter Parker before he realizes his enduring feelings for MJ. Jean Grey would then use her abilities to restore MJ's forgotten memories by the film's end. However, this theory faces criticism since Parker and Grey lack significant romantic history in Marvel comics, sharing only brief encounters.
Social media responses reveal strong opposition to MJ's return. One fan argued that restoring the relationship would destroy No Way Home's perfect conclusion, suggesting the introduction of Gwen Stacy or other comic book love interests instead. Another critic questioned the logic of mutants suddenly appearing in Spider-Man's universe without proper setup.
Alternative Character Possibilities
Comic book enthusiasts point out that Kitty Pryde would make more sense as a romantic interest, given her relationship with Peter in Ultimate Spider-Man. This connection provides stronger source material foundation compared to the Jean Grey theory. The random introduction of X-Men characters also seems unlikely before the planned soft reboot following upcoming Marvel events.
Critics argue that Jean Grey rarely interacts with Spider-Man in comic storylines, making her inclusion feel forced. The theory's reliance on mutant powers appearing without explanation creates additional plot complications that seem inconsistent with current MCU storytelling approaches.
The Case for MJ's Return
Despite fan resistance, compelling reasons exist for Zendaya's comeback. Peter's promise to reveal everything to MJ after Doctor Strange's spell created an emotional obligation. The coffee shop scene, where he tearfully realized she didn't recognize him, established unfinished business between the characters.
Parker's current isolation, having lost MJ, Ned, and Aunt May, creates a tragic situation where he lives alone with no one remembering his true identity. While some argue this allows character growth and franchise evolution, others believe Peter deserves happiness after his tremendous sacrifices. Having one person remember him could provide the emotional support needed for future adventures.